Nonsense, horsefeathers, and idle musings from a decade in South Korea (2002-2012).


24 July, 2004

Respectfully Yours

By Aaron
24 July, 2004

Something happens every morning and it unnerves me. Not that it happens to me every morning, but the idea that it's happening at all is vaguely unsettling. I'm referring here to what I call "the gauntlet." Every morning at 10:00 AM, when Korean department stores and supermarkets open, the sales staff line up at their positions within the store in order to greet the first customers of the day. As you walk through the store, these folks bow to you and then scurry off to their fishmongering, gimchi-making or trying to sell me women's cosmetic items. This whole production includes two parallel lines of middle-aged women at the front doors who bow to you and through which you have to walk if you want to get into the store.


For me, this is all too reminiscent of my days as a third-string, seventh grade football player. During practice the coaches would toss us a ball and we'd have to run through two collapsing lines of defensive lineman whose only goal in life was to not get their asses sent back to the McLaren School for Juvenile Reprobates. The coaches called this The Gauntlet and it used to scare the wholehearted hell of out me, which might explain why I've yet to become comfortable with people bowing to me.

One spring morning in Seoul, I tried to avoid going through all this by walking behind the bowing women. I might as well have been wearing a giant chicken suit as confused as these women looked. They all tried simultaneously bowing to me and to the customers who were behaving themselves and it just threw their whole respectful charade into a very un-Korean disorder.

I use the word 'charade' here because Korea, not unlike other countries, is obsessed with the notion of superficial courtesy. The Korean language is nothing if not hierarchical and one must change their verb endings depending on the level of respect demanded by the person they're addressing. Naturally this doesn't mean that you actually respect the person - you might, in fact, think he's a proper jackass - but somehow you can't let him know this.

Of course, none of us is so naive as to think that these polite words will translate into actions with any regularity. The same people calling me 'Aaron-ssi' or 'Aaron-nim' (essentially, Mr. Aaron) seem always to be the first ones to push right through to the front of the same line in which I happen to be standing (there's an absolute oblivion to the idea of queues here, but that's another rant entirely). At these times, the old adage 'actions speak louder than words' often comes to mind, but I can't think about it for too long because I usually have to elbow a pissy old geriatric out of the way so I can actually accomplish whatever it was I came to do.

Those of you reading this are no doubt thinking, "but, Aaron, don't we cloak our words in these empty formalities in every country? Does the American shopkeeper really mean it when he says, 'have a nice day?' Aren't humans, at their basic DNA level, just a pack of insincere toads?" And you're right, of course, every society has cultural mores very similar to those of Korea, but Korea sets itself apart in its noticeable lack of anything outside spoken courtesy. No one holds doors for those behind them. People push into the subway before anyone can get off. Drivers seem to live for plowing pedestrians in intersections or on sidewalks. People feel entitled to act rudely toward anyone younger than them or who might not have an 'equal' job to theirs. And the list goes on. I don't want to suggest that Koreans are a rude, mean-spirited lot, but for all their obsession with polite speech, one would think it might flow over into everyday life a bit more.

I'd like to think that I respect people not because of their age or their position in the world but rather because, if pressed, I'd admit that anyone taking up space on the earth deserves at least a modicum of respect. If I don't know that person, though, they certainly deserve neither more nor less respect than the next person. If you're Nelson Mandela, I might change my verb endings, but otherwise, I couldn't care less if you're the CEO of the Chia Pet empire or the man who hauls away my garbage.


08 July, 2004

You With the Point...Be Quiet

By Aaron
08 July, 2004

One thing I've learned during my two-plus years in Korea is that you never win debates/arguments/'discussions' with logic. The place would drive Socrates to insane drunkeness. Koreans, on the whole, value emotion and 'how something feels' over what most would consider to be common sense. In choosing a place to build a house, say, Koreans have historically tended ignore factors like flood plains, fault lines, soil factors, etc. in favor of what can only be described as a sixth sense, one which may or may not prove to be an accurate teller of fortune. Combine all of this with the Confucian idea that "the boss is always right simply because he/she is the boss" (even when she's wrong, she's right), and perhaps you'll understand what drives westerners so mad at times.

More recently and more directly related to me, I mention the latest round of discussions with my boss. I should first note that she's a helluva business woman for whom I have immense respect and who cares deeply for her school and her students. And she's generally pretty good about asking for and listening to input from her teachers, though at times it's clearly a cursory gesture, her mind already being made up. That qualification aside, however, some of her business decisions are staggeringly nonsensical.

To wit:
At present, she is consumed by the notion of doing a summer intensive session which would involve teaching an extra three hours of English grammar to students who pay for it for a period of three weeks (split by summer vacation into two sessions, actually). Now, the reasons for doing this session are few in my eyes. Come to think of it, I can't really see any reason for it. On the other hand, the reasons for not doing it are too numerous to mention in this small space, but suffice it say they run the educational, business and logistical gamut.

Now, not being one to keep his opinions to himself, I was straightforward in sharing my feelings with her, as were several other teachers. None of what we perceived as logical arguments, however, were of any use in this situation. Recall, though, that I had a tonsillectomy two weeks ago and the throat is still a bit sore, especially after teaching a full classload every day. So, I mentioned that I couldn't promise that I'd be up to teaching eight hours of classes each day so soon after my surgery, and - as per the usual - it seems that pity accomplished what no amount of reason and clear-headedness could: canceling those cursed classes.

All of this is not to say that I or the other teachers are in the absolute right with our 'logic' in this instance (though it just so happens that we are), but rather to illustrate the seeming irrelevence of rational thinking in some - if not all - decisions here in Korea (this being the same place where, a few years ago, the government of Seoul decided that the best way to solve the litter problem was to remove all public trash cans from the streets. "If we put garbage cans out," they reasoned, "it'll give people the idea that they're supposed to use them." You can imagine that the trash didn't disappear with the trash cans).

Slowly but surely, I'm learning these lessons and I might just make it as a lawyer in this country yet.

A Brief Postscript...

As I expected, the intensive sessions have been canceled. Nevertheless, that's Emotion:1, Aaron's Free Time:1, Logic:0.